Array
(
    [fullTitle] => Is the fact that other people believe in God a reason to believe? Remarks on the consensus gentium argument.
    [abstract] => According to The Consensus Gentium Argument from the premise: “Everyone believes that God exists” one can conclude that God does exist. In my paper I analyze two ways of defending the claim that somebody’s belief in God is a prima facie reason to believe. Kelly takes the fact of the commonness of the belief in God as a datum to explain and argues that the best explanation has to indicate the truthfulness of the theistic belief. Trinkaus Zagzebski grounds her defence on rationality of epistemic trust in others. In the paper I argue that the second line of reasoning is more promising and I propose its improved version.
    [authors] => Array
        (
            [0] => Array
                (
                    [givenName] => Marek
                    [affiliation] => Pontifical Faculty of Theology in Warsaw
                )

        )

    [keywords] => Array
        (
            [0] => Consensus gentium argument
            [1] => common consent argument
            [2] => epistemic trust
            [3] => epistemic authority
            [4] => Thomas Kelly
            [5] => Linda Trinkaus Zagzebski
        )

    [doi] => 10.24204/ejpr.v10i3.2591
    [datePublished] => 2018-09-17
    [pdf] => https://www.philosophy-of-religion.eu/menuscript/index.php/ejpr/article/view/2591/version/528/2164
)
"Loading..."

Is the fact that other people believe in God a reason to believe? Remarks on the consensus gentium argument.

Marek
Pontifical Faculty of Theology in Warsaw

DOI: https://doi.org/10.24204/ejpr.v10i3.2591

Abstract

According to The Consensus Gentium Argument from the premise: “Everyone believes that God exists” one can conclude that God does exist. In my paper I analyze two ways of defending the claim that somebody’s belief in God is a prima facie reason to believe. Kelly takes the fact of the commonness of the belief in God as a datum to explain and argues that the best explanation has to indicate the truthfulness of the theistic belief. Trinkaus Zagzebski grounds her defence on rationality of epistemic trust in others. In the paper I argue that the second line of reasoning is more promising and I propose its improved version.

Keywords: Consensus gentium argument

Download PDF